Godoy Medical Forensics

Specialty Areas

Our experts work with both criminal and civil attorneys. If your case involves medical records, traumatic injury, or requires expert medical testimony, we can help — regardless of which side of the aisle you’re on. For more information about the services we offer on these cases, visit our Services page, or use the Criminal Case and Civil Case buttons above to tell us about your case.

Strangulation testimony is full of numbers that sound authoritative and do not hold up. The pressure thresholds routinely cited in court have no validated human studies behind them, and one widely repeated figure traces to an 1897 reference. The claim that irreversible brain damage occurs in three to five minutes has no forensic study supporting it. The familiar injury-visibility percentages describe photography thresholds rather than whether injury occurred — a 2023 scoping review found reported absence of injury ranging from 17 to 93 percent across studies. Population statistics cannot be reliably applied to an individual case.

Our experts review the medical records and photographic evidence, assess whether the findings support the conclusions drawn from them, and evaluate the scientific reliability of the testimony and sources on the other side. That includes Daubert and Rule 702 analysis and cross-examination strategy. We also educate the court on what strangulation does to the body, which symptoms point to hypoxia, and why the absence of visible injury — or of petechiae — does not settle the question either way.

This work is drawn from Science of Strangulation, presented at the 76th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences. We also review pediatric strangulation cases, where the findings differ meaningfully from adults.

Sexual assault cases frequently come down to whether the allegations line up with the findings of the forensic examination. Our team includes nurses certified as SANE-A and SANE-P who perform these examinations themselves, and who can review sexual assault examination reports for patients of any age, from young children through adults.

We explain what an exam can and cannot establish, where the documentation is incomplete, whether the findings are consistent with the history given, and how evidence was collected and handled. We consult and testify for both prosecution and defense.

Burn injuries raise difficult questions about how and when an injury happened, and whether the explanation offered fits the wound. Our experts review the medical records and photographs to explain the type, depth and pattern of the burn, the likely mechanism of injury, and whether it is consistent with the history given.

Our team includes nurses with clinical burn experience in both adult and pediatric patients, who can walk an attorney or a jury through the treatment course and what the documentation does and does not establish.

In gunshot cases the details decide the question: entrance and exit wounds, the path of the projectile, and what the treating team documented in the moment. Our experts review the medical records, imaging and autopsy findings to explain the injuries and the treatment timeline.

We also tell attorneys something the chart will not. Treating physicians are frequently wrong about which wound is entrance and which is exit, because in the middle of saving a life that call is often made quickly and by size alone. Knowing where the medical record is reliable and where it is not can change how a case is built.

Our nurses have completed continuing education in forensic pathology, which enables them to review autopsy reports and translate them for the attorney. We assess whether medical conditions contributed to the death, sort out the traumatic injuries, and explain them in terms a jury can follow.

We also review cases where findings were read as homicide but have another explanation. A number of natural conditions and ordinary post-mortem changes are commonly mistaken for inflicted injury, and identifying them early changes the shape of a case.

Child Abuse – Abusive Head Trauma

Abusive Head Trauma is one of our areas of expertise. We generally have at least one of these cases going through our office on any given day. Non-accidental trauma cases involving retinal hemorrhages, intracranial bleeding, and cerebral edema are complex and involve several specialty areas of medicine. Our experts will review the medical records and help determine what kinds of experts may be needed. We will assess for mimics, determine the timeline of injury, and provide opinions about causation.

Child Abuse – General

Bruises and breaks are the common thread in these cases. Our nurses will review the case for medical causes such as rickets (vitamin D deficiency that weakens bones), Osteogenesis Imperfecta (Brittle bone disease), and coagulopathies (blood disorders). We will also assess the injuries to analyze the timeline. You will be ready for trial with the right types of child abuse experts and a strong knowledge of the medical components of your case.

Child Neglect and Failure to Thrive

In neglect cases it is particularly important to have an expert that has experience reviewing the records to look for underlying conditions that may have contributed to the failure to thrive. If the child has medical conditions it can make it difficult to determine the reason for the lack of weight gain and growth. There are also congenital conditions that may not have been ruled out effectively. Knowing the cause of the patient’s failure to thrive or wasting is essential for effective case development. If medical abuse or Munchausen’s Syndrome by Proxy is suspected, we can help assess the child’s medical conditions to analyze what is true or fictitious. We can help you sort through the records and find the right child abuse expert witnesses for defense or prosecution testimony.

Our team includes ICU and emergency nurses and emergency physicians who have treated and evaluated patients with traumatic brain injury at the bedside. That clinical experience is what allows them to speak to the pathophysiology of a head injury, its severity, the mechanisms that could have produced it, and the contributing factors that complicate the picture — whether a presentation is a stroke or a TBI, for instance, and which mimics, including intoxication, could account for what was observed.

We review the records and imaging to determine what the documentation actually supports, and we address post-concussion syndrome and the long-term cognitive, behavioral and psychiatric effects of traumatic brain injury, which can matter as much at sentencing as at trial.

Bruises, abrasions, lacerations and fractures rarely tell the story they first appear to. Reading them correctly starts with the mechanism behind each one. An abrasion is a friction injury. A laceration is a blunt force injury in which tissue splits under impact, and it is frequently mistaken for a sharp force wound — a misread that can change the entire theory of a case. Our experts know the characteristics that distinguish blunt from sharp trauma and name each wound for what it actually is.

Patterned injuries matter for the same reason. When a wound carries the shape of the object or surface that caused it, it can corroborate or contradict a version of events on its own. We examine the records and photographs for pattern, distribution, and whether the injuries are consistent in age and mechanism with the allegations.

We look just as hard for the other explanation. Bleeding disorders, bone disease, medications and ordinary accidents can all produce findings that resemble inflicted injury — and dating a bruise by its color is not reliable, a point that often goes unchallenged.

Stab wounds and other sharp force injuries raise questions the medical record often answers poorly. Our experts distinguish stab wounds from incised wounds, and both from the blunt force lacerations they are commonly confused with — a distinction that frequently decides how a case is understood.

We review the records, imaging and autopsy findings to address what the wounds can and cannot establish. Wound depth is a good example of what they cannot: tissue compresses and shifts under force, so a wound track can measure deeper or shallower than the weapon that made it, and depth is an unreliable guide to blade length. We speak to the real limits of what a wound says about the weapon used, the presence or absence of defensive injuries, and which injuries were survivable and for how long. We also examine how the wounds were documented in the first place, since measurement and description at the bedside are often imprecise.

How a child is interviewed can shape an entire case. Our child forensic interviewers are seasoned social workers with extensive experience conducting forensic interviews, qualified to interview children, adolescents and developmentally disabled adults. One of our interviewers is bilingual in Spanish and can both conduct and review interviews in Spanish.

We also review and analyze interviews that have already been conducted, assessing whether accepted protocol was followed and whether the questioning may have shaped what the child said.

Our forensic toxicologists have worked both in the laboratory and on the stand. They address drug and alcohol levels, how substances affect the body, and how testing is performed and interpreted, in DUI, homicide and assault cases.

That includes the questions that decide these cases: what a concentration can and cannot establish about impairment at the time in question, how a blood sample was drawn and handled, and the limits of the testing method used.

My first criminal case literally dropped in my lap. I was subpoenaed for a patient I had taken care of at Stanford University Medical Center and ended up getting a different case with that same defense attorney. The case had 1200 pages of medical records and the attorney was at a loss trying to sort through them all. Hiring a doctor was expensive and he didn’t think he really needed someone to testify, he just needed someone to help him understand how the injuries occurred. I reviewed the records and was able to help him understand that the medical records didn’t support attempted murder for his client. That defense attorney literally jump started my consulting business.

Tara Godoy | Owner of Godoy Medical Forensics, Inc.

Our unique background in working with both criminal and civil attorneys gives us a perspective that you will not find anywhere else. We are able to synthesize and analyze medical records in any kind of case.

Forensic Nurse Experts — Nationwide

We have a full team of Registered Nurses who consult and testify. Our Forensic Nurse Experts all have bios on our team page.

Trauma & Emergency Room Physicians

Our emergency medicine experts have consulted on stroke, cardiac disease, blunt and penetrating trauma, sexual assault and pediatrics, and speak to the severity, mechanism and clinical course of acute injury.

Orthopedic Surgeon Expert Witnesses

Our orthopedic experts address fractures and musculoskeletal injuries: severity, mechanism, the forces required to produce a given injury pattern, and whether the findings are consistent with the account given.

Child Forensic Interview Specialists

Seasoned social workers qualified to interview children, adolescents and developmentally disabled adults, including an interviewer who is bilingual in Spanish.

Forensic Toxicologists — Nationwide

Experience in drug levels, effects on the body, and testing of drugs and alcohol. DUI, homicide and assault related toxicology.

Contact Us

Call

925-425-7182